| Dr.
Anthony Amato,
Center for Rural and Regional Studies, Southwest State University
Customs and Costumes: Ritual, Play, and Performance
This paper investigates
the role of play and performance in ritual. By focusing on several
lifecycle and holiday rituals of the 19th and 20th century Carpathian
Mountains, the author of this paper addresses the place of ritual
in people's lives. Drawing on archival records, earlier ethnographic
studies, and his own thick description, the author focuses on play
and performance in four specific contexts: wedding festivities,
funeral games, post-Easter festivities, and caroling and mumming
at Christmas. In the Carpathians, play and performance have permeated
all four of these solemn and festive occasions in such a manner
that serious and lighter forms are frequently indistinguishable
from one another. A closer inquiry reveals a delicate balance between
formality and festivity. Both lifecycle and holiday rituals demonstrate
the play imperative's ability to convert the outrageous into something
that is acceptable and even desirable. At the same time, participant's
emphasis on propriety and proper acts has helped channel play and
create a chorus out of disparate and cacophonous symbols and meanings.
Through varied ritual, residents of the Carpathians have been able
to say many things, and regularly recurring festivities and conventions
in form have allowed participants to address a range of experiences
and work out many possible meanings. In exploring forms and occasions,
the author makes a case for the importance of local knowledge and
for seeing ritual in terms of specific performances, places, and
processes as manifest in events. A better appreciation of play,
formality, and locality allows scholars to unravel the tangle of
expressions and transformations intertwined in rituals.
Bridget
Blomfield, Claremont
Graduate University The Language of Tears: The Azah Ritual of Shi'ite
Women Immigrants
The azah ritual plays an important
role in the spiritual and psychological development of female Shi'ite
Muslim immigrants in the United States. Having brought their religious
traditions with them from Iran and Iraq, these women have carved
a niche of light into American culture. In investigating its role,
this paper will examine various aspects of the azah ritual, how
it supports the creation of sacred space internally and externally
and the use of the body as an instrument to access the divine. The
benefits of the ritual and its psychological implications to the
participants will be presented. A study of the importance of Matam
and azah, which means sorrow, will be explored as a ritual that
commemorates suffering and death as well as relationship to the
dead during Muharram, where devotion to the Shi'ite Imams and their
Mother, Lady Fatima is a crucial means of intercession between God
and humanity. Through the chanting, movements, and weeping inspired
by the azah, the suffering is made real and embodied in the female
participants bestowing on them agency and authority in an often
prejudiced Western culture. Whether the tears are shed for the symbolic
loss of the past or current sorrows in their lives today, the lamenting
process allows women to express the emotion of grief, to shed sympathetic
tears that are healing for self as well as community. An investigation
of the body of the community and how it "moves" as an essential,
collective response to emotion will be explored. Finally, a look
at what Westerners can learn from this ancient grieving process
that unites the participants through body prayer and bonds them
physically and spiritually. This paper is an ethnographic sketch
that is part of a forthcoming book about the City of Knowledge School
and its participants in Pomona, California.
Dr.
Ronald Burris,
Notre De Namur University & American Baptist Seminary of the West Martyrdom
or the Baptism in Blood
In the teaching of Tertullian
and how this affected or laid the foundation for North African Christianity.
As a result of this martyrdom, Christians begin to develop various
Rituals and celebrations around their dead martyrs - and this affected
the Church in North African in many ways.
Dr.
Agnes Irene Caldwell,
Department of Sociology, Criminal Justice and Human Services, Adrian
College "Keeping Your Head Down"; nationalist Responses
to Loyal Order Parades in Portadown, Northern Ireland 1945-1967
A recent focus of research
in Northern Ireland examines the conflict around the Loyal Order
parades. The majority of studies look at the identity and meaning
surrounding theses parades created through ritualized acts from
the Unionist/Protestant community's perspective. While these studies
admit the Nationalist/Catholic community finds these parades offensive
and threatening, virtually no studies document why such opinions
exist. This study addresses the Nationalist community's perspective
on Loyal Order parades in Portadown, Northern Ireland. Using a qualitative
case study from intensive interviews, focus groups, and content
analysis, shows how the tactics of the Nationalist/Catholic community
are mediated by colonialism, the political opportunity structure
and collective identity of which they are a part. Specifically,
I extend resistance tactics to Portadown, Northern Ireland from
1945-1967. While scholars assert that Nationalists in Northern Ireland
did not resist their second-class position until the civil rights
movement in the late sixties, evidence demonstrates both a methodological
and analytical weakness in that claim. Nationalists did not resist
their position, however it was done "behind the scenes"
and known only to that community. Furthermore, resistance was not
directed toward individual experiences such as discriminatory practices
in housing and employment, but on the collective experience around
Loyal Order parades.
Dr.
John Cash, Folklore
Institute, Indiana University Crossing Genres: Commemoration in Reenactments
and on Memorial Day
Reenactments are increasingly
the object of study because of the representations of history they
provide. Two theoretical approaches to these representations are
available to the researcher: the literary theory of narrative, and
the analysis of the tourist experience. The problem with the former
is that the reenactment is not a narrative, but rather a genre of
symbolic performance; the problem with the latter is that, typically,
only a single genre of performance is analyzed. Moreover, in neither
approach is the transformation inherent in ritual and festival genres
treated satisfactorily. In this paper I will critique these two
approaches, and, proceeding from a description of the reenactment
as a performance genre with a particular structure, I will discuss
the changes in audience, communication, representation and transformation
when the genre of performance changes from reenactment to Memorial
Day commemoration. This paper is based on the final chapter of my
dissertation, "Borrowed Time: Reenacting the Civil War in Indiana."
Zsuzsanna
Cselenyi, Department
of Folklore and Ethnomusicology, Indiana University Dancing Drums: Powwow
at IU (video)
This film documents
the Second Annual First Nations at IU Powwow, held on March 28-30,
2003 at Indiana University Bloomington. It focuses on the views
of the organizers and of the participants about the functions and
impact of a Native American powwow held in fairly a new context,
especially on a university campus, which not only draws people from
all walks of life, but also has a capacity for wide-spread education.
The main issues addressed include cultural appropriation, education
and awareness, and native and hobbyist representations and their
repercussions in indigenous and academic circles. Those interviewed
include some of the organizers, native and non-native students who
participated in the organizing and supervising stages of the event,
dancers and vendors, drums and singers, as well as spectators. The
significance of the film lies in its capacity to shed light on a
recent outgrowth of a cultural practice that has been going through
dramatic social and cultural changes since its birth in the early
20th century and is expected to reflect the changing roles of indigenous
expressive cultures within the greater fabric of American life.
It also represents the efforts of college powwows to dispel stereotypes
associated with American Indians, because "seeing Native people
in person provides a whole new perspective and a more accurate understanding
of their unique culture" (Dr. Wesley Thomas).
Dr.
Ariane Dalla Dea,
Department of Anthropology, University of California-Irvine The Theatricality
of Culture and Politics: the Use of Theatre of the Oppressed in Participatory
Democracy
The oppressed in Latin
America traditionally have used popular theatre as a form of social
and political expression. A radical shift occurs when it is the
power structure that applies theatre as an instrument of power to
empower its citizens. The city of Santo Andre in Brazil employs
the popular format Theatre of the Oppressed (TO) to stimulate civic
participation in the democratic process, establishing a new meaning
and function to TO. Augusto Boal adapted many drama techniques building
this live, interactive theatre medium during the 1960s as a political
resistance tool to the Brazilian power structure of that time. TO
uses the actor's life experiences as a script calling for the spectator's
intervention to offer solutions to complex problems that he/she
faces, and who, for the most, have experienced them at a certain
level. from the anthropological perspective, the government's appropriation
of what is a traditionally activist tool raises two key questions:
1) what are the implications of government-sponsored programs to
intervene and promote democratic practices, such as participatory
citizenship? And 2) how does the city government mobilize the citizenry
to inform of their rights and to participate in the democratic process
using TO techniques?
Kurt
Edwards, Theatre
Department, Bowling Green State University The Ceremony of Cars: My experience
growing up at the Indianapolis 500
Using Turner's concepts
of communitas, flow, and rites of passage, this presentation examines
white, male, middle-class, middle-American heritage through the
experience of modern motor racing. My goal is to create a looking
glass through which we can see some of the issues, pressures, and
problems inherent in developing men through a rite of passage in
the Indy 500 paradigm. By examining my father's experience as it
relates to my own experience, we can see parallels that are buttressed
by Turner's ideas. I first explore my father's Indy 500 experience,
then examine his experience through Victor Turner's theories, and
finally, try to make sense of this rite of passage as it pertains
to my own familiarity. Using autoethnography (the double meaning
of "auto" is intended), I am attempting to grapple with
my own epistemological understanding of growing up in a family that
puts authority in the "driving" if its male children through
a rite of passage ceremony in attending an automobile race, specifically
in this case, the Indianapolis 500.
Ivie
Erhahon, Assistant
Chief Research Officer & AG Head, National Council for Arts & Culture,
Nigeria Death and Traditional Mortuary Rites of The Edo Society
Kay Williamson classified
Edo as a member of the Edoid family, which belongs to the (new)
Benue -Congo languages. This new Benue-Congo is a subgroup of the
Niger-Congo languages. In the Edo society, mortuary rites vary according
to clan, locality, and the rank, status, and circumstance of the
deceased. It is the prayer of the Edo that parents "go" (predecease)
their offspring(s) and senior siblings their juniors. Again, the
degree to which the deceased has fulfilled his social destiny determines
the Edo attitudes to death. The most dreaded fate in the society
is to die sonless, or childless. In a sense, funeral rite is the
most potent symbol of the parents. The Edo believe that one who
is not properly buried cannot gain access into the society of his
deadkin and associates, hence one throws this question: "Why do
you want children?" the response is often: "So that they may bury
me well". For his survival as a social being, the Benin man is dependent
on the performance of the mortuary rites of his children. Children
of the deceased should perform the rites, with the senior son leading
the role and no person plays an active part in the funeral rites
for someone junior to himself. Children and childless adults are
buried unceremoniously by the ighele and iroghae (youths) in the
community. The traditional mortuary rites in the Edo society involves
rituals and sacrificing of animals, etc, etc. When the full mortuary
rites are accorded, in the case of the ordinary people, the take
seven (7) days and for the Monarch, fourteen (14) days. This paper
treats the traditional rites for a man who is survived by a son
or more. In it, we shall look at Edo Social Organisation: kinship,
domestic and family groupings, agnates and other kin, the different
stages and procedures involved in the rites.
Kate
Ferris, Department
of History, University College London, United Kingdom Death in Venice:
The fascistisation of funerals and the rituals of death in 1930s Venice
Drawing upon a chapter
of my PhD thesis, which considers cultural experiences in the everyday
lives and life cycles of Venetians under fascism, my paper proposes
to address the impact of fascism on funerary rituals and the experience
of death in Venice during the 1930s. Historians of Italian fascism
have long debated the extent of the fascist regime's desire and
ability to infiltrate the so-called private sphere(s) of ordinary
people's lives: my inquiry, which analyses the nature of funereal
ritual in 1930s Venice and, in particular, the way in which 'fascism'
sought to appropriate commemorative rites and symbols and introduce
novel ones in order to create and propagate a new fascist identity,
can help towards mapping the experiences and responses of 'ordinary'
Italians to the infiltration of fascist ideals, policies and the
regime apparatus into their day-to-day lives. The paper also engages
with historiographical debates relating to modernity's supposed
'denial of death' and the transnational trend for cults of commemoration
following the unprecedented scale of bloodshed and loss of life
of the First World War. The paper will seek to demonstrate the ways
in which Italian fascism sought to appropriate funeral rites and
experiences of death in Venice with the use of a number of case
studies; accounts of the funerals, reported in the Venetian press,
of a cross-section of Venetian society, ranging from celebrated
members of the Venetian establishment, including the Patriarch and
the leader of the local Fascist women's organisation to Venetians
of more 'humble' origins, who died either in rather unusual circumstances
or fighting in the Fascist campaigns in Ethiopia and Spain. It is
expected that this paper will address not only the degree of the
authorities' success in 'fascistising' funerals and death in 1930s
Venice, but will also argue for the tenacity of more long-standing
and widely held attitudes and rituals of death provided by national
narratives and Roman Catholic discourses.
Jeff
Gordon, Department
of Geography, Bowling Green State University A Common Ritual Upon Reaching
The Age of Majority: Legal Drinking and Gambling
Legal drinking and gambling
are common rites of passage for those reaching the age of majority.
For many people this achievement is a long-awaited and highly anticipated
milestone in their lives. People so inclined feel they should celebrate
and party when this very special time arrives. This includes the
heady rush of indulging in formerly prohibited (i.e., as a minor)
drinking and gambling. They want to enjoy their time of metamorphosis
leading into the freedoms associated with adulthood. In this very
purposeful adventure they break old restrictive boundaries and lose
inhibitions. It can be a magical and surreal experience likely defined
by those coming-of-age as "awesome." This ritual in which young
adults first exercise their new freedoms is modified by geography.
Legal drinking and gambling depend in part on laws restricting where
such activity can occur such as riverboats, Indian reservations,
gambling casinos, etc., which vary from state to state. Thus, not
unlike pilgrims, these young adults seek out in-state casinos as
destinations or make a pilgrimage to meccas in other states like
Las Vegas.
Dr.
Phillip A. Grant, Jr.,
History, Pace University The 1939 Dedication of the Baseball Hall of Fame
The official dedication of
the Baseball Hall of Fame was held at Cooperstown, NY on June 12,
1939. The ceremony was designed not only to honor the most outstanding
performers in the history of the major leagues, but also to commemorate
the 100th anniversary of the introduction of baseball in the United
States. Presiding over the festivities at Cooperstown were Judge
Kennsaw M. Landis, High Commissioner of Baseball, and James A. Farley,
Postmaster general of the United States. Also participating were
the Presidents of the National League, American League, the Baseball
Writers Association of America, and most of the executives of the
16 major league teams. Inducted into the Hall of Fame were Connie
Mack, Walter Johnson, Cy Young, Grover Cleveland Alexander, George
Sisler, Eddie Collins, Napoleon Lajoie, Honus Wagner, Tris Speaker,
Ty Cobb, and Babe Ruth. It was estimated that at least 10,000 people
assembled at Cooperstown to witness the tributes paid to these illustrious
retired ball players. The attendees had the opportunity to enjoy
a lively exhibition game, involving such well-known contemporary
players as Mel Ott, Billy Herman, and Hank Greenburg. The gathering
at Cooperstown became an annual ritual in the 65 years since 1939.
Dr.
Gregory Price Grieve,
Department of Religious Studies, University of North Carolina-Greensboro
An Improvised Theory of Social Agency: Creativity, Festival Practice and
The Invention of Place In Bhaktapur, Nepal
This paper articulates
the improvisational aspects of the Nepalese city of Bhaktapur's
Cow Procession Festival (Gai Jaatra). The Nepalese study is the
first part of a five-year multiple- site ethnographic research project
that explores the role of creativity in public celebrations. A city
of around 80,000 inhabitants, Bhaktapur lies seven miles east of
Kathmandu. Celebrated in late August, the Cow Procession is an intimate
mix of death and carnival that commemorates those who have died
during the previous year with a procession of floats and a series
of satirical performances. My paper concentrates on a "forged"
(nakali) goat sacrifice that I participated in on August 19, 1995
around 5:30pm. Although the sacrifice was forged, there was little
apparent difference between this "forged" celebration
and an "authentic" festival. It had a procession, a goat
sacrifice, and even a ritual feast - all key elements of authentic
worship. So, I describe the sacrifice in this way not because I
thought it was forged, but because the Nepalis participating in
the sacrifice described it to me as such. I argue that the forged
goat sacrifice was an instance of social invention used by the area's
people to "improvise" themselves into a mandalically organized
lived world. Theoretically, I use performance theory filtered through
local notions of practice, to suggest that we should use Improvisation
Theatre ("Improv ") as a model for articulating human
creativity. Such a model understands invention as (1) stemming from
social problem-solving and "team work" rather than individual
psychological inspiration; (2) constituted by the cultural matrix
in which it is situated; and (3) as a performance rather than a
product. Understanding the improvised elements of the goat sacrifice
is significant not only for solving its "puzzle," but
also for offering a larger model for articulating how cultures use
public celebrations to invent place when faced with novel problems.
Dr.
Moni'm Haddad,
Israel Christian Feasts and Celebrations in The Holy Land
Palestine is considered
to be the native land of Christ and the cradle of Christianity.
During the ages, especially the last few centuries, Christians in
Palestine were a minority, and the rulers of the land were non-
Christians. They continued to live here, in their homeland, and
to celebrate their feasts, ceremonies and rituals, more or less,
according to the "mode" of the ruler, and his policy:
tolerant with other religions or not. At the first half of the twentieth
century Palestine was put under the British Mandate, according to
a resolution of the League of Nations. H.M the King of the United
Kingdom, declared in his council for Palestinian affairs to ensure
religious autonomy for the Christian communities in Palestine. In
this period of the British Christian Mandate, the Palestinian Christians
practiced their religious freedom and celebrated their rituals and
feasts freely, as far as possible. In 1948 the state of Israel was
established, during the war of 1948 many Christian communities were
destroyed, and the people were obliged to leave their own homeland
and to move to the neighboring countries turning to be refugees.
Christian sanctuaries were destroyed, and Christian properties were
confiscated or blockaded, (just for example: many acres of the land
of Jerusalem where the official authorities' buildings are built
belong to the Christian properties). Apparently, the religious freedom
and autonomy granted to the Christian communities in Palestine by
HM King of the United Kingdom was respected, and Christians continue
to enjoy it officially and in some fields of life. Unfortunately
its implementation is different, too much different. The Christian
minority who continued to live inside Israel felt quickly the changes
of the regime: until now Sunday was considered to be the official
rest weekend day, from now Saturday became the official rest weekend
day, and Christians were obliged to work on their holy Sunday, any
worker or employee who refused to work on Sunday - was taking sever
risk to be fired and to lose his work and job. The same procedure
affected the Christian celebrations, ceremonies, feasts and rituals
inside Israel: at the beginning Christians continued to celebrate
their feasts, little by little the laws, orders and rules were changed,
and Christian workers and employees were forbidden from celebrating
their feasts and rituals. Even appeal to the court of work affairs
didn't help, and any Christian who wants to be religious and celebrate
his feasts, will take big risk of losing his work and job. This
non-just situation reached its peak during the historical visit
of HE Pope John Paul II to Israel, when Christian workers were not
allowed to leave their work to meet him. And it is claimed, until
now, that Christians here enjoy their religious autonomy and freedom.
Dr.
David Harnish,
College of Musical Arts, Bowling Green State University The Anatomy of
Balinese Temple Festivals and the Role of the Performing Arts
Balinese temple festivals,
the largest and most public expressions of religion in Bali, Indonesia,
celebrate the re-consecration of the temple. With an estimated 25,000
temples on the island holding festivals every 210 days (the Balinese
year), such events generate frequent ritual behavior and ideation.
In fact, early Western reports on the festivals helped craft the
touristic and scholarly image of Balinese as deeply religious and
exotic people. Though it is problematic to concisely define festivals
due to their colorful diversity around the island, similar frameworks
with marked stages operate in each one. Of particular importance
are the performing arts. Music, dance and /or theater fulfill many
of the essential rites that constitute a festival, and are often
an acknowledged rite unto themselves. For instance, festivals nearly
always begin with gamelan (ensemble) performances that act to call
together both human and divine participants, and topeng (masked)
dancing frequently accompanies and complements the priestly presentations
of offerings to deities. This presentation will explore the essential
elements of temple festivals and the functions of the performing
arts to drive the events to successful completion. I will also discuss
the rich variety of temples and their meanings and importance in
constructing, and maintaining Balinese culture, and will present
some specific festival examples. Other subjects broached include
the values of the performing arts, the histories and discourses
that they manifest in the festival atmosphere, and the changes that
some festivals have recently experienced due to intrusions of state
and state-sanctioned religious bodies.
Jeremy
Hockett,
Department of American Studies, University of New Mexico Mass-Observation's
May the Twelfth and Burning Man: Ritual Reflexivity for an Ethnographic
People.
On May 12, 1937 a daring
and obscure experiment in ethnographic reflexivity, known as "Mass-Observation"
(M-O), was initiated. Attempting what was called an "Anthropology
of Ourselves," a team of avant-garde English anthropologists
devised a plan to study "the beliefs and behavior of the British
Islanders," and the" so-called other nation of the workers
or the poor." The ethnography produced by M-O, entitled May
the Twelfth, focused on the coronation of King George VI following
the "great national crisis" of King Edward the VIII's
abdication. It was to be "the observation of everyone by everyone,
including themselves. "In this paper I argue that Burning Man
can be understood as an "ethnographic ritual" - a type
of liminal ritual for reflexive modernity that invites participant
observation, as individuals are encouraged to reflect on their own
culture, and their own roles in contributing to and constructing
that culture. Burning Man is in its own right a ritual worthy of
observation, much like the Coronation of George VI was for Mass
Observation. But with Burning Man it is the ritual itself that observes
rather than the ritual (and people's responses to it) that is observed.
In both cases, however, reflexive knowledge is produced, the former
doing so unconsciously, as it were, while the latter does so consciously
and strategically as its main purpose. In contrast to the mass observation
of a cross section of England on the day of one of its most powerful
rituals - the coronation of a monarch - in which the "team"
of observers is the vehicle of reflexive knowledge, Burning Man
- the carnivalesque ritual itself - becomes the vehicle of reflexivity
as participants become de facto ethnographers of their own culture.
This is best understood in light of the example M-O offers. Quoting
from the May the Twelfth report, James Buzard writes, and as its
techniques aimed to negate those of the State, M-O renders itself
the "new master of social magic," the production of May
the Twelfth becoming "a transforming ritual curiously shamanistic
in its own right," by means of which M-O "takes on the
shaman's knowledge and authority even as [it] represents the scientific
interpretation, and hence the secular negation, of the shaman's
occult culture of magic. "Thus, "May the Twelfth presents
itself as both record of and response to these official efforts,
at once their imitation and critique."
Dr.
Julia Huston Nguyen,
History, Texas A&M University-Corpus Christi Celebrating Church and State:
Holidays in Antebellum Louisiana
In antebellum America, church
and state often intersected in the celebration of holidays. This
paper will analyze that relationship in Louisiana, a state where
economic, social, political, ethnic, and demographic changes were
occurring at a rapid pace during the first half of the 19th century.
Some Louisiana holidays, like days appointed for fasting or prayer,
were set aside for religious devotion by a local, state, or national
government. Others, like Thanksgiving, July 4th, or January 8th,
were secular holidays whose primary commemoration took place in
a religious setting. In celebration of either type of holiday, Louisianans
and their governments exposed the values that their society upheld.
When designating religious and secular holidays, local, state, and
national governments often hoped to reinforce certain principles.
Foremost among them was patriotism, especially important in a new
state with many citizens who were not especially happy about being
Americans. Many of the values surrounding Louisiana holidays were
specific to the state and its unusual circumstances. The population-
made up of Catholic Creoles of French and Spanish descent, Anglo-Americans,
and recent immigrants from all over Europe- was often in conflict,
warring over social, economic, and political power in the young
state. Many holiday commemorations during the early 19th century
recognized these tensions as they celebrated unity and a single
American identity. During the 1850s and the secession crisis of
1860-61, holiday celebrations reflected the questions and concerns
that Louisianans had about their place in the nation. As special
days set aside from the everyday routine of antebellum life, holidays
uncover many of the tensions of Louisiana society as well as the
way that clergymen, civic leaders, and ordinary citizens attempted
to resolve those tensions. My analysis of such occasions will bring
new insights to the complexities and challenges of Louisiana society.
Rachel
Kulasza, Department
of Popular Culture, Bowling Green State University Gone, But Never Forgotten:
Creativity in the Humanization of Practices Surrounding Pet Death
This presentation will examine
some of the physical aspects of how the death of a pet is culturally
dealt with in the United States, focusing specifically on my 2003
ethnographic research with various individuals and businesses located
in Illinois, Missouri, and Ohio. Pet death is typically humanized;
thus the practices surrounding a pet death resemble funerary rites
and death rituals we recognize as characteristic of how cultures
throughout the United States treat human death. In accordance with
how and why pet death is humanized, whether at home or in a more
public sphere, such as a pet cemetery or memorial garden is the
expressed level of creativity and individualization in each action
and choice made. At the same time, these creative performances are
remarkably similar and parallel to those familiar actions surrounding
human death, such as choices made in how the body will be displayed
and memorialized in a funeral service, what objects are included
in the casket, and what is left behind at the grave site, how to
mark the grave, and the significance of what items visitors leave.
Such private aspects allow for uninhibited creativity of these humanized
death procedures that personalize and individualize each pet as
a unique and important member of the family group. Likewise, the
creativity surrounding pet death is folkloric in that a select group
is communicating their physical and emotional loss of a pet whom
is loved as a member of the family; and thus communicating their
beliefs through various artistic expressions in the actions and
choices made concerning pet death as a humanizing practice.
Dr.
Nirmal Kumar,
Delhi University, India As a Muslim King Invents Hindu Imperial Rituals:
The case of Mughal ruler of 16th Century North India
The Marxist historians have
generally been describing the Indian State especially in early modern
and pre-British period as agricultural leviathan with unlimited
political penetration. To them the Mughal State (1526-1740s) was
able to implement its policies and programs with remarkable ease.
This linear and unproblematic development of society and polity
in early modern centuries needs to be questioned. We see this so
called strong and politically competent Mughal State taking various
measures to buttress its political authority and ensure people's
compliance. The Mughal State under its first effective ruler Akbar
took measures to appropriate the support of the Hindu people. Akbar
very consciously reinvented the obviously Hindu Imperial/royal rituals
like Jharoka Darshan, Tula Daan, celebration of birthday according
to solar calendar, participating in Hindu festivities. Though he
celebrated other than Hindu festivities too like a Parsi Nauroj
but since the population of other religion people were next to nothing
his overtures to the Hindu assume more than all. Akbar's attempt
to rationalize the state and make it acceptable to the Hindu majority
was novel by all count. I would like to argue that contrary to the
dominant Marxist view that the Mughal State was mainly and only
'Agrarian Leviathan', the all powerful Mughal state did try to appropriate
cultural and social allegiance of the majority Hindus and gave them
the message that the Muslim kings were in direct succession to the
Hindu chiefs and rulers. Such acts increased the political legitimacy
and social acceptability of the alien Mughal rulers. Assessment
of the nature of pre-modern and early modern states in India needs
a fresh look to redefine the is very urgent in the light of misapplication
of Marxist theories to them, many a times willfully ignoring the
cultural and ritual aspects of the state because that would have
made the state's analysis solely on economic grounds weaker.
Dr.
James Brooks Kuykendall,
Music Department, Calvin College Pomp & Consequences: Tracing the
Origins and Influence of a "Ceremonial" Style in English
Music, c. 1880-1980
In the late Victorian
era - and in the midst of a renaissance of English music - four
prototypically English musical idioms coalesced to form a distinctly
national style that served as the perfect accompaniment to newly
thriving ceremonialism: echoes of Handel were forged with elements
of hymntunes, marches, and patriotic and nautical airs. Although
often regarded as vulgar and bombastic, this combination proved
to be potent. As musicologist Wilfrid Mellers has mused, this Pomp
and Circumstances sound was able to "send shivers down reluctant,
even resentful spines". The potency of this "God-is-an-Englishman
music" has lingered in the century since, even after the British
Empire has ceased to be a geo-political entity. The music seems
sometimes dignified and restrained, sometimes bombastic and triumphant,
sometimes wistful and nostalgic. Perhaps because of this flexibility,
the Elgarian ceremonial style has maintained a lasting place as
a stylistic signifier for later composers. This paper examines briefly
the origins of this style in the 19th century, and then turns to
a variety of 20th century manifestations (from the hymn "Lift
High the Cross" to the films The Dambusters and Star Wars).
Linda
J. Lee, Program
in Folklore & Folklife, University of Pennsylvania A Place to Remember:
The Salem Witch Trials Memorial and the Politics of Memory
This paper explores how memorials
and monuments embody cultural meanings and anchor those meanings
in the landscape. Specifically, I analyze the range of meanings
associated with the Salem Witch Trials Memorial in Salem, Massachusetts.
Dedicated on August 5, 1992, this memorial is a production of space
that carries multiple cultural meanings. The design of the memorial
interprets the past for the present, drawing substantially of elements
from the legend tradition of the witch trials. Recognizing the meanings
inherent in this space helps to explain the role that this Memorial
plays in transmitting Salem's heritage message. Residents of the
city of Salem have had a complicated relationship with its notorious
past, which is manifested as ambivalence in how the events of 1692
are remembered. The Salem Witch Trials Memorial honors the memory
of the victims of the witch trials of 1692; 19 people were hanged
and one person was pressed to death. In contemporary Salem, there
are very few locations with any direct connection to these events.
The exact location of the execution site is unknown, and most of
these victims did not receive proper burials. The construction of
this memorial (which is adjacent to the city's oldest cemetery)
established a new public space for both remembering the victims
of the witch trials of 1692 and enacting a variety of folklore performances.
This paper is analytical in nature, drawing on theories of collective
memory and forgetting, the significance of space, and the performance
of heritage and historical discourse. I analyze how the memorial's
design incorporates symbolic elements of the dominant local legend
tradition; consider the ritual, tourist, and folklore performances
that take place there; and explore the meanings related to the site's
heritage message.
Dr.
Barbara A. Looney,
Independent Scholar Reunions at the Top: the Crazy Horse Memorial Annual
Volksmarch
The Crazy Horse Monument,
currently being carved out of solid pegmatite-granite mountain in
the Black Hills of western South Dakota, will become the largest
single memorial to any one person in the world. Sometime mid-century,
when the work is complete, the final form will show the upper torso
of the Lakota war chief, Crazy Horse, astride his stallion, arm
outstretched. The statue will rise 500 feet high and 600 feet long.
Between the Indian's arm and his horse will be a space capable of
holding the entire carving of the national shrine of the four presidents
at Mt. Rushmore, located less than an hour away. With work in progress,
the only time the public can get close to the unfinished carving
is during the annual 10 kilometer Volksmarch to the top, held the
first weekend each June. This event, sanctioned by the American
Volkssport Association, has grown from several hundred participants
when it was first organized in 1986, to more than 15,000 walkers
this past year. This paper examines how the annual march brings
attention to the Native American world and legacy of Crazy Horse
in ways that simultaneously embrace, enlarge, and inspire, yet also
distort and redirect. The climb to the summit is both a tribute
and a carnival. Marchers honor the Indian and his carver by their
presence, even as their participation directs the focus to personal
reunions and occasional wacky celebrations. Through narration and
color slides, this paper explores the very public ritual that has
emerged at the memorial site of a most private and mysterious Lakota
man who refused to be photographed or to sit for a portrait.
Dr.
Keith A. Mayes,
Department of African American & African Studies, University of Minnesota-Twin
Cities Memory and the Politics of Black Holidays: African 96Americans,
20th Century Commemorations and the Formation of a Black Calendar
This paper examines
the black holiday phenomenon in the 20th century. It will first
begin by acknowledging the black commemorative tradition of the
19th century, particularly around emancipation holidays and their
continued importance to African-Americans in the new century. As
freedom became a reality through the progression of 19th century
politics, African-Americans created new celebrations around the
ending of the slave trade and various emancipation days (Emancipation
Proclamation, Juneteenth, 13th Amendment, etc.). I will argue in
this paper that blacks not only continued some of these holidays
in the 20th century (mainly Juneteenth) but created new holidays
germane to their ongoing experiences in American society, such as
Black History Week, Brown v. Board of Education commemorations,
and Martin Luther King, Jr. The paper will also examine the growth
of Black Power holidays and their attempt to negate dominant American
traditions: Kwanzaa (the so-called black Christmas), Umoja Karamu
(the black Thanksgiving), Black Solidarity Day (first Monday in
November before Election Day), Malcolm X commemorations, and Black
Love Day (the black Valentine's Day). Taken together, these holidays
gave rise to a distinct black commemorative calendar and underscored
importance of historical memory and the politics of holiday creation
in black America. The politics of black holiday making, however,
involved various constituencies having differential accesses to
power, which led to uneven holiday legacies. Some black holidays
like Juneteenth and Martin Luther King established commissions and
acquired wider recognition in American public culture while others
have remained confined to black institutional spaces.
Kris
Nesbitt,
Curriculum in Folklore, University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill
Angel Babies: Women's Webs of Loss and Transformation
I propose to present
a portion of my Masters thesis for UNC's Curriculum in Folklore,
which focuses on a new and growing phenomenon in the public memorialization
of death - the widespread creation of memorial websites. My particular
area of interest includes sites that memorialize lost neonatal,
perinatal, and stillborn infants. The websites are an expressive
form used in different ways by different women to speak about their
own lives and, more broadly, the human experience of life and loss.
Sites like these are a new phenomenon, arising as Internet access
spreads and the opportunities for easy web design and hosting grow.
The sites stand at a particular moment arising from new technology
and changing cultural expectations for public self-expression and
the meaning of community. The sites are also born, I argue, from
the contestations and contradictions of millennial American culture.
Infant loss websites reveal negotiations and contradictions between
recent dramatic changes in social and family structure, increasing
capabilities - and shortfalls -- in medical technology, societal
views and expectations of infant mortality, and our culture's views
on motherhood itself. Amidst all of these other issues, however,
the idea of how we express and recover from grief stands at the
forefront. Again and again, the women who create these sites write
of their feelings of isolation. Others in their lives deny their
grief. However, websites like these provide a form of resistance
against cultural norms against openly revealing the pain of loss.
Self-expression breeds transformation and healing. Women connect
with others who share their pain over the Internet, and form close-knit,
if electronically-connected, networks of support. By publicly displaying
their disenfranchised grief through their memorial sites, the women
develop and interweave an emergent ritual into their daily lives
and continue to inscribe the lost infants within their life experiences.
Dr.
Karl Neuenfeldt,
Contemporary Communication, Central Queensland University, Australia Badu
Island Tombstone Unveilings
Tombstone Unveilings
are the main mortuary rites of Australian indigenous Torres Strait
Islanders. They take place several years after a person's death
and relatives are expected to contribute to the event and travel
to the gravesite from the Australian mainland. The rites are unique
in Australia and mix older Melanesian and newer Christian traditions.
Music and dance are crucial to the events. On December 13 2003 there
were 6 such unveilings at Badu Island. The paper comments on: the
morning gravesite ceremonies accompanied by Christian hymns sung
in procession; the evening program of celebratory and competitive
secular singing and dancing that extends for many hours [often 4
pm to 4 am]. The event is a mélange of celebration, pilgrimage and
competition, as local dance groups from Torres Strait and Papua
New Guinea present well-rehearsed and entertaining programs to resident
and returning audiences.
Dr.
Colin Quigley,
Program in Culture and Performance, University of California-Los Angeles
Cultural Performance, Public Display, and Magyar Minority Identity in
Transylvania
The Central Transylvanian
region of Romania is currently home to a mixed population of Romanians,
Magyars (Hungarians), and Roma (Gypsies). During my fieldwork there
in 1997-99, I recorded a variety of public performances that reference
Magyar identity in several frames: projections from Hungary that
incorporate the Transylvanian Magyars into a nationalizing ideology;
locally configured representations responding to the view from Hungary;
Magyar-Romanian and/or Magyar-Roma distinctions; and intra-Magyar
relations within Transylvania. The performances I examined fall
at various points along a folkore-folklorism spectrum. In this presentation
I focus the visit of a Hungarian folkdance ensemble to a village;
the anniversary celebration of "20 years of Tanchaz (dance
house)" in the city of Kolozsvar, presented in the Hungarian
Opera House; and, carnival customs in a small town currently undergoing
limited tourist development. I will use a short video to illustrate
the Carnival example, "Here lies Mr. Farsang: Carnival in Torocko".
In a number of largely Catholic Hungarian communities throughout
Transylvania, the population observes Carnival through a variety
of traditional customs. Torocko is one such town where Carnival
customs kept rather muted under the former socialist regime have
been reinvigorated since 1990. Farsang, as the custom is known in
Hungarian, now serves as a high-profile public event that draws
visitors to the community from throughout the surrounding region.
The young men process in elaborate costume, in the form of a mock
wedding/funeral cortege. Various masked figures accompany them,
harassing the onlookers as they go. The event culminates in a lengthy
oration, bidding farewell to the year, personified as the deceased
farsang dome, that is, Mr. Farsang. The text cites the value placed
on this custom and its links to Hungarian tradition. Social tensions
are addressed in a humorous and at the same time self-deprecating
ironic tone. The commentaries it makes on the growing tourist economy,
local, and national politics are both subtle and biting.
Dr.
Mojca Ram_ak,
Scientific Research Center of the Slovene Academy of Sciences and
Arts, Institute of Slovene Ethnology, Slovenia Out of Fear, Close
to Reconciliation
The paper is based on
oral sources, 76 life-stories of Carinthian Slovenes of rural origins,
the minority on the linguistically most endangered southern area
of the Austrian part of Carinthia. Spiritual dimensions of death,
as seen in Carinthian life-stories, include unexplained premonitions,
with pure mythological elements which lead toward solving of eternal
uncertainty with death, religiously strengthened notions of different
afterlife existence, family's and community's attitude toward the
death (which do not always confirm stereotyped notions of traditional
funeral rituals), vanishing Slovene epitaphs on the gravestones
and energetic rejection of presenting unnecessary violent death
on the television. Empirical ethnological investigation was focused
on private mourning and on death as an existential and social problem
among the Slovenes in Austrian Carinthia. Different methods and
strategies for understanding and acceptance of death are discussed:
from simple rational logic to the sophisticated mediative ways of
selflessness and detachment needed for acceptance of the unavoidable.
Memories about death, compared to other turning points of life,
are described rather sparingly. Interviewees talked about death
of their relatives and acquaintances fleetingly, partially and with
respect. During the years they have turned pain of loss into a bitter
awareness of life's shortness and its uniqueness. The interviewees
talk about death, which is somewhere nearby, as an unwanted intruder,
but it does not invoke fear anymore - only reconciliation with life
as it is. Different destinies from narrators' earliest years were
accompanied by death, for instance women in childbed, who sometimes
didn't get satisfactory medical assistance; death accompanied the
incautious during their working activities, those who went to the
army and those who were killed in the Nazi concentration camps.
Of those who for whatever reason committed suicide, interviewees
spoke weighted - many times they changed chosen words, as if they
would try to express respect toward the intimate decisions of those,
who could no longer bear the world (or the world no longer tolerated
them).
Dan
Shope,
American Culture Studies Program, Bowling Green State University
Upon This Rock I Will Build My Church: British Israelite Belief,
Symbols, and Celebration and Its Connection To Herbert W. Armstrong's
World-Wide Church of God Beliefs and Symbols
In their book Negotiating
Identity: Rhetoric, Metaphor, and Social Drama in Northern Ireland,
Buckley and Kenny assert a belief system of direct Jewish ancestry
among many people in Ireland and England. Today these believers
are referred to as "British Jewry "or "British Israelites."
They are considered an influential group in the United Kingdom,
the United States, Canada, and Australia. Linked to this long-held
tradition is a similar, if not exact, belief held by many who were/are
members of Herbert W. Armstrong's World-Wide Church of God. This
paper is an analysis of this belief among many residents in Ireland,
England, the history of this belief, and the symbols used in celebration
by fraternal orders in Ireland such as the Orange Order, and its
connections to the same belief among former World-Wide Church of
God believers and their everyday lives.
Pastor,
Dr. Brett H. Smith,
University Baptist Church, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Liturgies for Learning and Labor: Rituals for Public Worship at the University
of Illinois, 1897-1880
The University of Illinois
(then called the "Illinois Industrial University") was
among the first of the new wave of public agricultural and mechanical
schools that arrived on the American scene during the later half
of the 19th century. Though expressly designed to break with the
normative church-related liberal educational tradition of its day
- including the absence of theological studies or the training of
clergy - the I.I.U. community nevertheless was quite intentional
about cultivating a Christian identity and ethos. In their very
first advertising pamphlet sent to Illinois high schools, the I.I.U.
trustees said they desired to create a "Christian culture"
at the University. This paper will describe how rituals of public
worship sacralized their life together as a learning community,
and catechized the faithful in the I.I.U.'s quest to become a state-sponsored,
yet Christian school. Jonathan Baldwin Turner, a Yale graduate and
Congregational minister, provided the theoretical grist for this
new type of education, insisting that the I.I.U.'s graduates would
become robust and useful human beings, trained for industrial progress.
The traditional pallid, monkish theologue with his musty Greek and
Latin would have no place in a new and bustling America, he argued.
So, Baptist minister and I.I.U. President John Milton Gregory and
the other campus leaders made the training of a utilitarian and
healthful human being their goal. Gregory had recently published
a speech entitled "The Right and Duty of Christianity to Educate,"
in which he spelled out religion's divine mandate to provide such
moral formation for the nation's citizens. At Illinois, he coined
the school motto, "Learning and Labor", arguing that an
ideal Christian man or woman would balance mental and physical work,
resulting in a more whole human being. Gregory drove this message
home by preaching in daily and Sunday chapel services on the campus,
a room where "Learning and Labor" was posted on the wall
as an iconic reminder. He wrote theologically revealing hymns about
the motto and other pertinent topics to the I.I.U., which worshippers
sang together at various services. Along with regular chapels, he
led the community in public rituals during special events like baccalaureate,
commencement, cornerstone layings, and building dedications. Other
dignitaries in Illinois political and educational life spoke from
the I.I.U. pulpit as well. By describing the music, prayer, preaching,
facilities used in worship, this paper will demonstrate through
primary sources how the I.I.U. community engaged in a unique and
fascinating amalgamation of non-sectarian Christian worship in a
state-sponsored, public university setting.
Andy
Soper, Department
of Popular Culture, Bowling Green State University Body, Brotherhood,
& Bereavement: 9-11 Tattoos of the FDNY
This is a presentation on
the performance of grief as evidenced through the 9-11 memorial
tattoos of the FDNY community. This presentation will explore both
the private and public display/performances of these images, including
analysis of aspects of images, range of personal involvement in
design, placement, and the rational for displaying such as memorial.
I will also be using Signs of War and Peace (Jack Santino) as a
springboard for discussion involving the performance of communal
and personal grief.
Arunas
Vaicekauskas,
Department of Ethnology & Folklore, Vytautas Magnus University,
Lithuania The Death and Society: Lithuanian Velines (All Souls Day)
Mihnea
Vasilescu, Department
of Sociology, University of Pittsburgh Burying the Past: Romanian Revolution
and the Heroes of the Revolution Cemetery
Romania was the only
country in Eastern Europe that overthrew the communist regime with
a bloody revolution. Almost 15 years after December 1989 Romanians
still don't know what the people who heroically lost their lives
actually died for, and who shot them. The bodies of those who died
in Bucharest are buried in the Heroes of the Revolution Cemetery.
Perfectly aligned marble crosses are decorated with pictures, statues,
and poems, which try to convey something about the personalities
of those who are buried there. Each of the post-1989 governments
avoided to thoroughly investigate how the revolution actually unfolded.
Currently, there are several competing accounts and interpretations
of those revolutionary days but the death of the revolutionaries
is still a question left unanswered. Because of this, the Heroes
of the Revolution Cemetery is not only a site of remembrance but
also a possible source of delegitimation. Ironically though, despite
the cemetery's potentiality for counter memory, it remains a key
location for yearly commemorations where governments in place organize
dull ceremonies and unconvincing calls for reconciliation are made.
Missing the unified voice of a representative group of revolutionaries
that are the legitimate heirs of the ideals of those who died the
cemetery ultimately becomes the place where the past is buried rather
than the source of its regeneration. This paper is concerned with
the ironical social location of this Cemetery within the public
memory as well as within the political life of post-revolutionary
Romania. from a theoretical point of view, it argues that sites
of remembrance can be used for useful political purposes by powerful
groups even when those sites are the sources of their contestation
and delegitimation.
Martin
Walsh, University
of Michigan San Martin Caballero: the Fortunes of a Pan-European Saint
and his Festival in the New World
St. Martin of Tours
is high in what we might call the second tier of Latin American
saints, and affords a manageable test-case for examining the transplantation
of a European saint's cult to the New World. St. Martin place names
are quite common in Mexico, Central America, and the Spanish colonial
areas of the United States, and the image of the "Charity of
St. Martin" (the saint's splitting of his cloak with a sword
to share it with a beggar) is familiar today in popular religious
iconography. This paper will survey the extent of Martin's cult
in the New World, from Columbus's naming of a Caribbean island in
his honor to church dedications at the end of the colonial era,
and will examine the various modifications to his feats day of November
11 when interacting with indigenous cultures, with special attention
to the fiestas of San Martin. Texmelucan (Puebla), Mexico and San
Martin Jilotepeque and San Martin Chili Verde, Guatemala. Some surprising
transformations took place. The European saint, known for his campaigns
against the vestiges of paganism in Gaul, fared surprisingly well
in the hybrid Christianity of the indios as the magical horseman
San Martin Caballero.
Dr.
Phyllis A. Watts,
Professor of Sociology, Tiffin University Remembering the Past:
Memorials along the "Trail of Tears"
Under President Jackson's
leadership, the Indian Removal Act became law, thereby forcing the
Indians - Cherokee, Creek, Choctaw, Chickasaw, and Seminole - from
their lands in the Carolinas, Tennessee and Georgia. As they marched
the eight hundred miles of forests, mountains, swamps, and wilderness
roads, many died. It is estimated that one of every four Cherokee
who started westward died along this route. The Trail of Tears starts
in Georgia and ends in Oklahoma. The U. S. Forestry and the National
Park Service officially recognized in 1973, a motorized route. I
drove this route, photographed, and gathered historical documentation
illustrative of the memorial erected at various sites along the
route. This power point presentation illustrates those designated
locations and Historical information located therein.
George
Williams, Media
Bureau, Federal Communications Commission Megalithic Sites and the Cosmic
Cycle of Rebirth
An important common feature
for a number of prehistoric megalithic sites is the alignment of these
structures with the summer or midwinter solstice. Strikingly, similar
features can be found in North American prehistoric sites, suggesting
that disparate prehistoric cultures shared similar cosmologies and rituals.
We examine these common themes, which appear to suggest the importance
of rituals regarding the sun, the earth mother, and rebirth. Additional
clues may be found from the Native American sweat lodge ritual, which
contains some of these features.
|