chemistry 100
September 12, 2001
Focus on Atomic / Molecular Model
Chemists believe in a sub-microscopic world
-
atoms-- as basic unit of matter
- parts of atoms -- especially
electrons
ultimate explanation of chemistry
chemical
bonds -- links between atoms
sub-assemblies
-
molecules
-
ions and ionic solids
- nonmolecular bonding (large lattices)
-
metals
assemblies
- how molecules collect, form liquids and solids
- how things get big enough to see
Back up a Little
Look at some basic issues of knowledge and science
- What do we actually see and observe
- directly acquired knowledge
-
EMPIRICAL observations
- color, smell, size, firmness
- will it burn, dissolve, melt
-
- Cataloging Information
- Develop a suitable vocabulary
- specific field-- specific vocabulary
- Find common features, create categories
-
- Finding Relationships
- Empirical Relationship
(example #1)
Heat an object and it gets a little larger
- seems to be almost universally true
- Empirical Relationship
#2
gas (balloon)-- press on it and it gets smaller
- liquid (cylinder) -- press on it and no change
- vocabulary: compressible, incompressible
- simplifications:
- liquids are slightly compressible
If relationship is
- general
- consistently true
- significant
becomes a LAW ( Empirical Law)
- Could even become mathematical in form
- Gases P x V = n x R x T
- a very useful form of a law
- law need not have an equation
Theory--
- Ideas: what's really behind observations
-
- Initially--
Hypothesis (intelligent guess)
- Could be simple idea
- Could be fairly outrageous, complicated set of ideas
- might also call this a theory
- use #1 of the word "theory"
-
theory is bit more than hypothesis
-
- Testing Hypothesis
- Look at existing observations--
- Make predictions--
- anything we don't already know
- Perform new observations
- review overlooked observations
- Perform new experiments--
- test the hypothesis
- well designed, critical experiments
- Look hard for alternative explanations
IF there is overwhelming
- support
- evidence
- acceptance
- theory (proposal, guess, idea)--
use #1 of word
gets accepted as theory (basis of the field) --
use #2 of the word
- These two (contradictory) uses of the word theory allow a lot of intellectually dishonest discussions
- ...
oh, that's just a theory and we know theories are often wrong...
-
- creationism and evolution is the most obvious example
-
-
...often, "theory doesn't explain everything, must be wrong"
Simplifications and Approximations
- we usually prefer the simplest explanation that fits the data
- a simple theory with a reasonable fit
- usually prefer to detailed theory with excellent fit
- a theory that focuses on some aspect of problem is often favored over a terribly complex universal theory
- but... we usually want to know that better theory is there and works even if we operate with the simpler models
- Theories (usage #2) are of course
- human intellectual creations
- could always be wrong or incomplete
- we could, of course, be totally deluded about everything
- what are the chances?
- how well founded are the ideas?
One test-- Plausible, Reasonable
- difficult to apply when ideas go beyond direct observation
- atoms too tiny to see or even detect directly?
- a universe too large to comprehend
- DNA storing an amazingly complex pattern
Example:
- model of atom as tiny solar system
- nucleus (sun) and planets (electrons)
- planets are populated by intelligent teeny beings
- telepathic (read our thoughts)
- worried about atomic experiments
- decided what we should think
- control the universe to fool us
- our science is "wrong"
- it's what they want us to believe
-
- do we reject this as implausible?
Models--
- simplified (working) versions of complex theories
- compare to Cartoons--
- simplified drawings, with emphasis
Draw an atom--- volunteers?
- Picture of an atom
- first of all, atom is too small to see
- "picture" is a distortion of the word
- tiny is a major feature (invisible image)
- tiny, distorted (tiny dot or many tiny dots)
- nucleus is home of most of the mass
- dot in a cloud
- charged (+) sign
- chemistry involves only the outside electrons
- electrons cover a lot of space quickly
- fuzzy cloud, forget the nucleus
- like a balloon (focus on size, shape)
- electrons seem to be divided into shells
- mostly energy (can't draw that)
- size (could show that)
- might let circles suggest energies
- (electrons as planets about a sun)
Atomic Theory
Atomic Models
- (simpler, visualization of the theory)
- we like to think with pictures
- Atoms exist, but are extremely small
- Atom is electrically neutral
- Atoms of an element are all the same
- simplification: discuss difference later as isotopes
- Atom seems to have two parts
- nucleus-- almost all the mass
- nucleus-- positive charge
- charges are multiples of a base unit- +1, +2, +3 ..
- nucleus has 1, 2, 3 ... protons (+ particles)
- also has neutron (about same mass, no charge)
-
- Electrons
- negative region (spread out all over)
- due to negative particles called electrons
- much lighter in weight
- equal number
-
- Simplifications:
- there is structure in the nucleus -- chemists generally ignore it
- can break nucleus into simpler parts -- leave that to physicists
- all chemistry takes place with electrons
- all chemistry involves only last few electrons
- typically no more than 8 electrons.
(ions, bonds, metals / electrical conductivity)
return to Chemistry 100 home page