"What's the best search engine? The one you learn to use well."
Bill Dedman, Power Reporting:
Resources for Journalists http://powerreporting.com/altavista.html |
| |
Finding
information on the Web can be difficult, especially if you're
unfamiliar with different search engines. Some search engines
are computer-generated indexes which search the Web or portions
of the it while other engines search sites gathered, indexed,
and organized by people. Sometimes, search engines are a combination
of the two. In addition to indexing and retrieving information
in different ways, search engines may vary in the search syntax
they understand. Some allow the Boolean operators (and,
or, not) in search statements; others allow what
Search Engine Watch calls "search engine math." In other words,
they understand pluses (+), minuses (-), and quotation marks
(" ") in search statements. Very few search engines understand
natural language--that is, typing something in as you would
say it. Natural language searching,even when it is permitted,
typically produces poor results. It's best to learn more about
search techniques.
To become an expert, pick two or three search engines, and then
become familiar with their features and the syntax they allow.
Otherwise, your search will always be compromised. If you want
to search as much of the Web as possible, try an engine like
Google.
If you are new to searching the Web, start with a directory
like Yahoo.
If you want sites that have already been evaluated by a reputable
source, try the Scout Report's Archives.
|
|
Becoming a WebWIZARD:
What you need to know:
Boolean
Operators (and, or, not)
| AIDS
and quilts |
This
search finds both words in same document. Both words have
to appear. AND narrows search results. |
| colleges
or universities |
This
search finds either word or both words in a document. At least
one word must appear. OR broadens search results. |
| Cleveland
not Indians |
NOT
eliminates terms and narrows your search. This search
will retrieve items about Cleveland but not about the Cleveland
Indians. |
"Search Engine
Math"* (pluses, minuses and quotation marks)
| +AIDS
+quilts |
The
plus sign requires terms to be present. Two or more terms
narrow your search. |
| colleges
universities |
No
signs will retrieve either word, not necessarily both. Your
search will be broad. |
| +Cleveland
-Indians |
While
the plus sign requires the presence of a term, the minus sign
eliminates a term. This strategy narrows your search. |
| "stock
market" |
Quotation
marks bind phrases. Use double quotes to bind a naturally
occurring, grammatically correct phrase to make your search
more precise:
"high school" "New York" "World Wide
Web" "Affirmative Action" |
+"New
York Stock Exchange"
-"American Stock Exchange" |
Combine
all three signs to create a powerful, precise search when
needed: This search will eliminate the phrase American Stock
Exchange but will retrieve the phrase New York Stock Exchange.
|
*"Search
engine math" is a phrase coined by Search
Engine Watch.
Three Search Engines: Google, Yahoo, Scout Report's Archives
| Search
Engine |
Features |
Suggested
Use |
Search
Tips |
Google
|
- Includes
more than 4 billion pages.
- Is a crawler-based tool that provides comprehensive coverage of the web and has the ability to retrieve highly relevant results.
- Also
provides access to images, usenet groups, and a subject
directory (topical browsing).
|
- Use
this tool when you want to search as much of the
Web as possible.
- Look
here for information on the "real" world: travel, weather,
movies, Web pages you know about, news, etc.
|
- Defaults
to AND (finds all words entered).
- Use quotations marks to keep phrases together.
- Understands search engine math
- Go to advanced search for a menu-driven search.
|
Yahoo
|
- Is a hybrid search tool consisting of a directory and listings of web sites compiled by people. Also ties into Google, a crawler-based tool.
- Has
a searchable and browsable directory.
- Provides
links to over half a million sites divided into more than
25,000 categories.
- Has
unevaluated sites suggested by users.
- Has
sites assigned to categories by real people called "surfers"
at Yahoo. Standards for inclusion aren't clear.
|
- Browse
to see what's available on a given topic.
- Look
here for information on the "real" world: travel, weather,
movies, Web pages you know about, news, etc.
|
- Defaults
to AND (finds all words entered).
- Use quotations marks to keep phrases together.
- Understands search engine math
- Go to advanced search for a menu-driven search.
|
Scout
Report's
Archives
|
- Links
to sites selected and reviewed by editorial staff.
- Contains
over 13,000 critically evaluated sites, 9,000 of which
have been cataloged, classified, and arranged according
to Library of Congress classification.
- Provides
a lengthy annotation.
- Is
browsable (by LC subject headings and classifications);
Is also searchable (Keyword and Advanced).
|
- Visit
this site when looking for more information aimed at an
academic audience. The site is intended
for higher education.
- Browse
to see what's available on a given topic.
- Check
here if you are having trouble finding reputable information.
|
-
The keyword search default is OR when two or more words
are searched . (An AND search isn't possible in the keyword
search.)
-
Use quotation marks to bind a phrase in both the keyword
and advanced search (e.g., "first aid," "United States,"
etc.).
-
Advanced search has a full range of Boolean operators.
Complex searches can be created with the menu-driven interface.
|
Wording
Your Search
Before you start typing words in a search engine, spend some time
putting your topic into words. Write it down if you want to keep track
of important concepts or keywords. In most search engines you can't
use natural language. That is, you can't search something by typing
a complete sentence or question.
For example, let's say that this sentence
captures the topic you're searching:
I want to find information about college students doing volunteer
work.
Possible search strategies:
| Google |
"college students"
volunteer |
| Yahoo |
"college students"
volunteer |
| Scout
Report Archives |
Use
the pull-down menus in Advanced search. In the first
box, type volunteer; in the second box, type students;
and in the third box type college. Leave the Boolean
operator AND as the connector. |
Troubleshooting:
Common Obstacles
- Too many
hits?
--Add to your search statement. Depending on the syntax that a
search engine understands, use AND or + to add a
new term.
- Not enough
hits?
--Try a different search engine.
--Check your search statement. Make sure it accurately reflects
what you're searching for.
--Use different search terms to express the same idea. Let's say
you're looking for information on the subculture of extreme sports.
After searching for subculture and extreme sports, you want more
hits. Try searching the term counterculture and/or naming sports
individually (skateboarding, snowboarding, etc.).
- No hits?
--Check your spelling.
- False
Hits?
-- Depending on the syntax a search engine allows, use NOT
or a minus sign (-) to eliminate the term that's throwing
off your search. Say, for instance, you're searching for information
on Jordan, the country, and you keep getting sites about
Michael Jordan. Eliminate Michael from your search,
and you're more likely to retrieve more appropriate hits.
- Problems
citing the Web page?
--Citing Web pages can be difficult. Sometimes, a page doesn't
have all of the elements required in a citation. In that case,
supply as much of the required information as possible. Your job
is to get your readers back to the sources you cite. See Module
5, which has information about APA & MLA style.
- Information
not scholarly or academic enough?
--You may find some scholarly information on the Web; however,
in general, you will be much better off using the Research Databases, which provide
access to scholarly literature. Many of the Research Databases
supply full-text articles, which are not freely available through
a search engine like Google or Yahoo.
- Not enough
time to search and evaluate Web sites?
--Visit Scout Report's Archives.
It's one of the few sites on the Web geared toward an educational
audience that provides access to already evaluated sites. To be
included in the Archives, a Web site has to have
a certain quality (according to their human reviewers, anyway).
- Not happy
with your search results?
--Remember that librarians at Jerome Library and the Science Library
specialize in finding information. Stop by and
let a librarian help in your search!
|